What’s Wrong with a Church Choir?






Introduction

When I first began the series on the Worship service, I discussed “singing” as the first subject. I also made mention that no mechanical instruments were being used nor choirs. Since then, comments have been made to me (on social media) in regards to both subjects. I will handle both of these today in separate articles. This is the second article that was sparked from discussion on social media.



A Comment from Social Media

As part of the discussion about the use of mechanical instruments, on social media, I made mention that choirs were also not a part of the worship service. This comment came to me about that subject…

If it is sing only, why are choirs, etc. eliminated? Is there somewhere in the Bible that says you can’t sing together? Even if you eliminate the instruments, why eliminate the groups?

My simple response to this was: Everyone means everyone as far a singing goes. I’ll go into more detail in this article. First, let’s return to the Old Testament.



Choirs in the Old Testament

First of all, let me say that I do not find the idea of choirs to be sinful. I have listened to and enjoyed the music of a variety of choirs over the years. They are a great way to celebrate Christ and praise God. The concept of choirs goes back to days of the Jews and the Temple. The word ‘choirs’ itself is only mentioned twice in scripture (Neh. 12:31, 40), and is used after the Jews had returned from Babylonian captivity (See my article on Thanksgiving Choirs for more about this event).

This is not to say that choirs didn’t exist beforehand. Like the use of instruments, choirs derived from the Tribe of Levi. Asaph was one of three chief musicians of King David and a series of psalms are penned by him (Ps. 50 and Psalms 73-83). The other two, Heman and Ethan; and their sons, were all in charge of the music. Both musicians and singers were all a part of the Levites (1 Chr. 15:16-19).


So Why not Choirs Today?

Going back to the comment from social media, the purpose of choirs today is indeed to praise God. However, when they are used in the worship assembly; they are the only ones singing and that makes the congregation an audience. As I stated in the other article, I find it unfair that this one group is praising God and I’m not.

Everyone, and that means EVERYONE, in the worship assembly should sing. Paul wrote in Ephesians 5:19, speaking to one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord. And again, in Colossians 3:16, Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom, teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord. God wants to hear every voice sing; whether you are an accomplished professional or tone deaf, He wants to hear YOUR VOICE. If a choir is singing, then you are not.



Conclusion

Matthew 28:18, And Jesus came and spoke to them, saying, "All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth.” If we believe this statement, then we can simply abide by what he has taught us in his scriptures. To add instruments or choirs in the assembly is going beyond what is written (1 Cor. 4:6; 2 Jn. 9).


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

09. Number Your Days

Image
  God’s Bucket List for You, part 2   Introduction In Psalms 90:10-12, Moses prayed, The days of our lives are seventy years; And if by reason of strength they are eighty years, Yet their boast is only labor and sorrow; For it is soon cut off, and we fly away. Who knows the power of Your anger? For as the fear of You, so is Your wrath. So teach us to number our days, That we may gain a heart of wisdom. We’re only give so much time here on Earth and it is up to us to make everyday count. Each day breaks down into just 1440 minutes and when you subtract to amount for school/work and sleep, it’s even less. We should appreciate the amount we have daily.   I’ve Got Plenty of Time How often have we said, or heard someone say, that they have plenty of years ahead of them to do this or that? Most young people believe that religion is for the older people; those headed into their twilight years that are “closer to death” than they were in their youth. Yet, they do...
Read more

06. Realize Your Self-worth

Image
  God’s Bucket List for You, part 5  Introduction to the series, click here Introduction One of the problems I suffer from, as do a lot of people, is a low self-esteem. We often make the mistake of basing our self-esteem on our family, friends, occupation, area we live in, and our home. Although all of that factor into our lives, they don’t have to be the main basis of our self-esteem. As part of His bucket list for us, God wants us to realize our self-worth by examining our lives according to His scriptures. If we are not following His word, as written, then we need to change and build up our self-esteem.   Moses’ lack of Self-worth In our previous article , we looked at Moses and the excuses he made to God as he didn’t want to lead his people out of Egypt. One of his excuses was a lack of eloquent speech. Here’s what he said in Exodus 4:10, Then Moses said to the LORD, “O my Lord, I am not eloquent, neither before nor since You have spoken to Your servant;...
Read more

IMMORTAL (I’m Mortal)

Image
(from 2013) Introduction “Do No Try This at Home” is a phrase generally seen as a disclaimer on certain television shows that feature dangerous stunts or other things in which professionals have been training to do for many years. Teenagers and young adults will attempt to imitate these very same stunts themselves. Why? Because it’s the thrill of the stunt and an opportunity to gain approval of their peers. To them failure is not an option as well as death. It’s a certain level of immortality that young people feel because, to them, their whole life is ahead of them and death only happens to old people. But as a preacher once said, “The Old must die and the young do die.” Definitions of Immortal The dictionary definition for immortal is ‘Exempt from Death’ or ‘Imperishable’.   In other words, you can never die or you live forever. But this is not true and we all, eventually, will die. In addition, the dictionary also defines immortal on the basis of a noun in...
Read more